E-ISSN:2456-3110

Case Report

Ayurvedic management of Eczema

Journal of Ayurveda and Integrated Medical Sciences

2024 Volume 9 Number 1 January
Publisherwww.maharshicharaka.in

Case report on Ayurvedic management of Eczema with special reference to Charma Kushta

Neethu Ks1*, Paul A2
DOI:10.21760/jaims.9.1.45

1* Neethu Ks, Assistant Professor, Department of Kayachikitsa, Ayurveda College Hospital, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India.

2 Ajay Paul, Associate Professor, Department of Kayachikitsa, Ayurveda College Hospital, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India.

Skin inflammation is referred to as eczema, also referred to as dermatitis. Erythema, vesiculation, and oozing are the symptoms of acute eczema, followed by subacute scaling and crusting and chronic lichenification. According to Ayurveda, Charmakushta which is one among the 18 types of Kushta can be correlated to chronic stage of eczema. This condition can be managed with Sodhana and Shamana principles mentioned in Kushta. The subjective parameter like pruritus is assessed with NRS(numeric rating scale) and EASI score (eczema area and severity index) was taken for measuring area or extent along with severity. Sleep disturbance was measured using atopic dermatitis sleep score (ADSS) and DLQI (Dermatology Life Quality Index) was also assessed. All these parameters were assessed before and after treatment and also after follow up. DLQI of the patient was 66.6%before treatment which was reduced to 26.6% after treatment and 13.3% after follow up. NRS score has showed a 5 point decrease in the score and ADSS showed a marked decrease in mean score after follow up. EASI score also showed a marked reduction from 22 to 8.6 after follow up.

Keywords: Eczema, Erythema, Charmakushta, lichenification, Dermatology life quality index, eczema area and severity index

Corresponding Author How to Cite this Article To Browse
Neethu Ks, Assistant Professor, Department of Kayachikitsa, Ayurveda College Hospital, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India.
Email:
Neethu Ks, Paul A, Case report on Ayurvedic management of Eczema with special reference to Charma Kushta. J Ayu Int Med Sci. 2024;9(1):288-293.
Available From
https://jaims.in/jaims/article/view/3041

Manuscript Received Review Round 1 Review Round 2 Review Round 3 Accepted
2023-11-16 2023-11-26 2023-12-06 2023-12-16 2023-12-24
Conflict of Interest Funding Ethical Approval Plagiarism X-checker Note
None declared Nil Yes 20.85

© 2024by Neethu Ks, Paul Aand Published by Maharshi Charaka Ayurveda Organization. This is an Open Access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ unported [CC BY 4.0].

Introduction

The term eczema refers to inflammation of the skin and is classified into endogenous and exogenous eczemas depending up on whether the causative factors are internal or external. Erythema, vesiculation, and oozing are the symptoms of acute eczema, followed by subacute scaling and crusting and chronic lichenification.[1]

A widespread, chronic, inflammatory skin condition marked by pruritus and recurrent remissions and relapses, atopic eczema or dermatitis is one of the endogenous dermatitis. It has links to other atopic diseases such as allergic rhino conjunctivitis and asthma. Atopic dermatitis affects 15 to 20% of people worldwide. 50% of cases appear in the first year of life, the majority do so within five years, and the remainder do so by the age of 30. It can be divided into 3 stages based on this: Infantile AD (2 months to 2 years), childhood AD (2 years to 10 years) and Adult AD. The majority of the individuals with atopic dermatitis report having had it as children. After the age of 18, AD affects 6% to 14% of people. Adults with atopic dermatitis develop small, erythematous, scaly plaques. In the acute stage, the lesion may ooze; in chronic cases, it may become dry, scaly and lichenified. It is triggered by stress, anxiety and depression in adults. Severe pruritus is the main outcome of this condition.

Ayurveda explains skin diseases under the main domain Kushta. Kushta, the word suggest any discolouration in the skin is having the involvement of three Doshas and Tvak, Raktha, Mamsa, Lasika as the seven pathogenic substances. The continuous and simultaneous involvement of these seven fold factors for a prolonged period and which are deep seated are involved in the pathogenisity. The Doshas travel through the Tiryak Siras to the skin through Raktha, Lasika and causes discolouration in the skin. Again, after discolouration of the skin, it starts to afflict the succeeding Dhatus, so this disease is having the two dimensional pathogenicity from inside to outside and vice versa.[2] So the treatment should be based on the involvement of Doshas at particular stage of the disease pathogenesis. Kushta is broadly classified into Mahakushta and Kshudra Kushta which is again classified into 7 and 11 respectively.[3] So a total of 18 types of Kushta and the Dosha involvement for each one were explained in the

classics. The treatment for this condition includes both Samana and Shodhana. By assessing the Dosha predominance at the particular stage of pathogenesis treatment should be provided like Snehapana for Vata, Vamana for Kapha, Raktha Mokshana and Virechana for Pitta.

Charmakushta is a type of Kshudra Kushta which is Vatakapha Pradhana Dosha and having symptoms like rough skin that resemble that of the elephant. Charmakushta can be correlated with chronic stage of atopic eczema where there is lichenification of the skin. A secondary skin lesion which is characterized by hyper pigmentation, thickened skin and with increased skin markings is known as lichenification.[4] The case taken here is a subject with chronic eczema having secondary lesions of lichenification and severe pruritis and was taken as a Vatakapha predominant Charmakushta and was treated with Shaman Aushadhis and Shodhana Chikitsa like Vamana.

The parameters like NRS (numeric rating scale), EASI score (eczema area and severity index)[5], ADSS (atopic dermatitis sleep score) and DLQI (Dermatology Life Quality Index) were assessed for measuring pruritus, area or extent along with severity, Sleep disturbance and quality of life of the patient respectively. All these parameters were assessed before and after treatment and also after follow up. DLQI of the patient was 66.6% before treatment which was reduced to 26.6% after treatment and 13.3% after follow up. NRS score has showed a 5-point decrease in the score and ADSS showed a complete decrease in mean score after follow up. EASI score also showed a marked reduction from 22 to 8.6 after follow up.

Case Report

A female patient aged 45, complaints of blackish discoloration since 2 yrs. distribution: asymmetrical widespread from axilla in bilateral sides, in groins, in flexures/wedges of mammary gland, below and around umbilical region and in some parts of lower limb with severe itching which is disturbing her sleep. Morning, she baths so many times so as to reduce the itch but in night she is experiencing more itching and when she scratches it becomes eroded and painful. Sometimes vesicles appear on the discoloured skin usually while taking some peculiar food. Occasionally Burning sensation present. K/C/O


allergy-asthma, hyperthyroidism-since 8 yrs. under medication for both. She consulted many allopathic hospitals with only momentary relief. So, she approached our hospital.

Diagnosis and assessment

Based on the history of the present illness and clinical examination, the condition was diagnosed. Signs and symptoms like erythema and vesicles with secondary lesion of lichenification were present in flexures with severe itching and disturbed sleep. History of bronchial asthma present.

The assessment criteria’s used were pruritus NRS (numeric rating scale), EASI score (eczema area and severity index), ADSS (atopic dermatitis sleep score) and DLQI (Dermatology Life Quality Index). Pruritus was measured using pruritus NRS where patient was asked to rate their itching each day from 0 to 10 based on the severity of their itching which is recorded on each day and weekly mean scores are taken. EASI score was taken based on the body regions affected and severity of the redness, thickness, scratching and lichenification. ADSS was also assessed by the self report of the patient, the impact of itch on sleep including 2-point assessment of difficulty in falling asleep and number of night time awakenings. DLQI was assessed with the help of a 10-point questionnaire which measures how much the patients skin problem has affected her life over the last week.

Table 1: Pruritus numeric rating scale (NRS)

Before treatment (1st wk.)After treatment (4th wk.)After follow up (8th wk.)
Mean score942

Figure 1: pruritus numeric rating scale

Table 2: Eczema area and severity index (EASI)

Before Treatment
Body regionrednessthicknessscratchinglichenificationSeverity scoreArea scoremultiplierRegion score
Head/ neck0000=0x0x0.10
Trunk2333=11x4x0.313.2
Upper limb1111=4x1x0.20.8
Lower limbs2323=10x2x0.48
After Treatment
Body regionrednessthicknessscratchinglichenificationSeverity scoreArea scoremultiplierRegion score
Head/ neck0000=0x0x0.10
Trunk1202=5x4x0.36
Upper limb1101=1x1x0.20.6
Lower limbs1202=5x2x0.44
After Follow Up
Body regionrednessthicknessscratchinglichenificationSeverity scoreArea scoremultiplierRegion score
Head/ neck0000=0x0x0.10
Trunk1102=4x4x0.34.8
Upper limb1101=1x1x0.20.6
Lower limbs1102=4x2x0.43.2

Table 4: Final EASI score

Before treatmentAfter treatmentAfter follow up
EASI score2210.68.6

Figure 2: Final EASI score


Table 5: Atopic Dermatitis Sleep Score (ADSS)

Mean scoreBefore treatmentAfter treatmentAfter follow up
Difficulty falling asleep420
Number of night time awakening7.400

Table 6: Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI)

Before treatmentAfter treatmentAfter follow up
DLQI score66.6%26.6%13.33%

Figure 3: Dermatology Life Quality Index

Intervention

Table 7: Internal medications

DurationMedicineDoseAnupanaFrequency
22-08-2022
to
14-0S9-2022
Aragwadhadi Kashayam[6] + punarnavadi Kashyam[7]20ml60 ml lukewarm waterTwo times a day before food
Vilwadi Gulika[8]1 tabletWith KashayamTwo times a day before food
22-08-2022
to
14-09-2022
Haridra Kandam[9]1 tablespoonWith lukewarm waterMorning after food
22-08-2022
to
24-08-2022
Avipathi Choornam[10]1 tablespoonWith warm waterAt bed time
25-08-2022
to
14-09-2022
Manibadra Gulam[11]1 tablespoonWith warm waterAt bed time
23-08-2022Anuloma DS2 tabletWith warm waterAt night
26-08-2022Pathyakshadhatryadi Kashayam tab1 tabletWith warm waterTwo times after food
7-09-2022Dasamoola Rasayanam + Karpooradi Choornam1 teaspoon + 1/4 teaspoonTwo times after food

Table 8: Bahirparimarjana and Sodhana Chikitsa

DurationTreatment
24-08-2022 – 27-08-2022Abhyangam with Jeevanthyadi Yamakam
Kashaya Dhara with Aragwadhadigana Kashayam
24-08-2022 – 27-08-2022Rookshana with Gandharvahasthadi Kashayam and Vaiswanara Choornam - ¼ tablespoon with the Kashayas mentioned above.
28-08-2022 – 04-09-2022Snehapana with Aragwadha Mahatiktaka Ghrita (internal administration of medicated ghee started with a dose of 25ml and gradually increasing the dose upto 230 ml)
05-09-2022Abhyangam with Jeevanthyadi Yamakam
Bashpa Svedam
06-09-2022Vamana (Emesis) with Yashtimadhu Kashaya, Ksheera, Lavanodakam
Samsarjanakrama (for increasing the digestive power after Vamana therapy)
09-09-2022 – 14-09-2022Abhyangam with Jeevanthyadi Yamakam + Aditya Paka Thailam
Bashpa Swedam
13-09-2022 – 14-09-2022Kashaya Dhara with Aragwadhadi Kashayam
Utkarshanam with Aragwadhadi Kashaya Choornam + Kashayam

Table 9: Discharge medicines

MedicineDose
Patola Katurohinyadi Kashayam + Aragwadhadi Kashayam20 ml + 60 ml lukewarm water
Vilwadi Gulika1
Haridra Khandam1tsp
Manibadra Gulam3 tsp
Manasamitra Vatakam1
Sidharthaka Snana Choornam + Aragwadhadi Choornam + Nimbi Haridradi ChoornamFor Utkarshana before bath
Jeevanthyadi Yamakam + Nalpamaradi ThailamExternal application
Ksheerabala ThailamFor Padaabhyangam
Kachooradi ChoornamFor Thalam

Discussion

Atopic dermatitis which is a type of endogenous eczema manifest as erythema, vesiculation and oozing in the acute stage and in subacute stage manifest as scaling and crusting with lichenification in the chronic stage. Skin diseases can be diagnosed on the basis of present pathogenic stage and the involved Dosha and Dushya in Ayurveda as Ayurveda classifies skin diseases under the umbrella of Kushta into 18 types. Based on the present status of the patient where she is having blackish discolouration in multiple areas including


flexures which are lichenified in most areas with severe itching which disturbs her sleep heavily can be correlated to Charmakushta which is Vatakaphaja predominant.[12] Treatment principles adopted here is Samshodhana which should be Snehayuktha along with the Samana Aushadhas which are Kushtaghna.[13] Here the condition is chronic and in atopic dermatitis filaggrin deficiency, poor epidermal Samshodhana Chikitsa lipid layer with increased transepidermal water loss and predisposition to bacterial and viral infections along with reduced itch threshold happens, so should be done with a proper Snehana given in Arohana Matra and Bahya Snehana is done in form of Abhyanga.

Patient is a known case of allergy and asthma with a hereditary predisposition of the same and was under medication for the same. So Punarnavadi Kashayam was started along with Aragwadhadi Kashayam as she had severe itching with disturbed sleep. Vilwadi Gulika was given along with that which will act as an antimicrobial and prevents infection and removes all kinds of Visha. Haridhra Khandam was prescribed to reduce the vicious cycle of allergies.

Snehapana was done with Aragwadhadi Mahathikthaka Ghritha for 8 days with the dose increasing upto 230 ml and Vamana was done after one day of Bahya Sneha and Sweda. Vamana was done with Yashtimadhu Kashaya, Ksheera, Lavanodakam and Nitya Virechana was done with Manibadra Gulam. Bahya Sneha was done frequently with Jeevanthyadi Yamakam which is having an antimicrobial action along with Kashaya Dhara with Aragwadhadi Gana Kashayam. Utkarshanam was done with Aragwadhadi Kashaya Choornam and Kashayam to reduce the thickness of the secondary lesion of lichenification.

The parameters like NRS (numeric rating scale), EASI score (eczema area and severity index), ADSS (atopic dermatitis sleep score) and DLQI (Dermatology Life Quality Index) were assessed for measuring pruritus, area or extent along with severity, Sleep disturbance and quality of life of the patient respectively. All these parameters were assessed before and after treatment and also after follow-up. DLQI of the patient was 66.6% before treatment which was reduced to 26.6% after treatment and 13.3% after follow up. NRS score has showed a 5-point decrease in the score and ADSS showed a complete decrease

in mean score after follow up. EASI score also showed a marked reduction from 22 to 8.6 after follow-up. The itching and sleep disturbance of the patient was able to reduce to a remarkable rate along with improving the quality of life of the subject. This case study brings out the effectiveness of our classical treatment and intermittent treatment support is needed for further reduction of the thickness and secondary lesions which are chronic in origin.

References

1. Yash Pal Munjal. API textbook of medicine. 10th New Delhi. Dr. Yash Pal Munjal For And On Behalf Of The Association Of Physicians Of India; 2015.

2. PM Govindhan Vaidhyan. Ashtanga Hrudayam, Nidanasthana. 14/3. Kodungallur: Devi book stall,2018, p:251.

3. Sharma R K, Dash B, editors. Charaka Samhita, Chkitsasthana. 7/21. Varanasi: Chaukhambha Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, 2012.p.323

4. Saurabh Jindal. Review Of Dermatology. 5th New Delhi. Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers; 2017.

5. Finlay AY, Khan GK. Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI)--a simple practical measure for routine clinical use. Clin Exp Dermatol. 1994 May;19(3):210-6. Available from: 10.1111/j.1365-2230.1994.tb01167.x. PMID: 8033378.

6. Sreekumar. Ashtanga Hrudaya, Sutrasthana.15/17-18. Thrissur: Publication Department, Harisree Hospital, 2008.p.381.

7. Sidhinandana Mishra. Bhaishajya Ratnavali. 42/13. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Surabharathi Prakashan, 2019.p.768.

8. R. Srikantha Murthy. Ashtanga Hrudayam, Uttarasthana. 36/84-85. Varanasi: Chowkhamba Krishnadas Academy,2006.p.357.

9. Sidhinandana Mishra. Bhaishajya Ratnavali.55/13-17.Varanasi: Chaukhamba Surabharathi Prakashan, 2019.p. 898.

10. R. Srikantha Murthy. Ashtanga Hrudaya, kalpasthana 2/21-23.Varanasi :Chowkhamba Krishnadas Academy,2006.p.543.

11. R. Srikantha Murthy. Ashtanga Hrudaya,Chikitsa sthana19/31-32.Varanasi :Chowkhamba Krishnadas Academy, 2006.p.477.


12. Agnivesha, Charaka Samhita, Vidyotini Hindi commentary by Kashiram Shastri and Gorakhnath Chaturvedi, Chaukhambha Bharati Academy; Varanasi, Part II, reprint 2006, Chikitsa Sthana 7/30, pp. 253.

13. Sharma R K, Dash B, editors. Charaka Samhita, Chkitsasthana. 7/21.Varanasi: Chaukhambha Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, 2012.p.324-5