E-ISSN:2456-3110

Review Article

Mootra-Ashmari

Journal of Ayurveda and Integrated Medical Sciences

2024 Volume 09 Number 06 JUNE
Publisherwww.maharshicharaka.in

An etiopathological study of Mootra-Ashmari with special reference to Urolithiasis: A Literary Review

Sonam KK1*, Avadhesh K2, Neelam G3, Deena NS4, Jai SP5
DOI:10.21760/jaims.9.6.28

1* Sonam Kumari Keshari, Post Graduate Scholar, Department of Roga Nidana Evum Vikriti Vigyana, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.

2 Avadhesh Kumar, Professor HOD, Department of Roga Nidana Evum Vikriti Vigyana, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.

3 Neelam Gupta, Professor HOD, Dept of Rachana Sharira, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.

4 Deena Nath Singh, Assistant Professor, Dept of Roga Nidana Evum Vikriti Vigyana, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.

5 Jai Shankar Prasad, Assistant Professor, Dept of Kriya Sharir, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.

Mootra-Ashmari is a disease of urinary tract which causes problems in many ways including passage of urine. The waste material when not dissolve completely in urine and obstruct urinary path then Mootra-Ashmari may occur which is termed as renal calculi/urolithiasis/nephrolithiasis in modern medical sciences. As per Sushruta Samhita, Ashmari is included in Ashtamahagada due to its fatal nature. Description of Ashmari is found in almost all Samhitas of Ayurveda for e.g. either as a type of Mootraghata (Acharya Charaka) or as a separate disease (Acharya Sushruta). Ashmari is one of the most common disorders of Mootravaha Srotasa. It is Kaphapradhana Tridoshaja Vyadhi. Pathya-Apathya is an important factor in Mootra-Ashmari. Urinary stones frequently occur worldwide. Prevalence rate of 1-5% are reported in Asia, 12% in India. it is very much important to prevent occurrence of the disease because of the dreadful complications caused by Mootra-Ashmari and its high chances of recurrence.

Keywords: Mootra-Ashmari, Urolithiasis, Renal Calculi.

Corresponding Author How to Cite this Article To Browse
Sonam Kumari Keshari, Post Graduate Scholar, Department of Roga Nidana Evum Vikriti Vigyana, Government Ayurvedic PG College and Hospital, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Email:
Sonam Kumari Keshari, Avadhesh Kumar, Neelam Gupta, Deena Nath Singh, Jai Shankar Prasad, An etiopathological study of Mootra-Ashmari with special reference to Urolithiasis: A Literary Review. J Ayu Int Med Sci. 2024;09(06):184-189.
Available From
https://jaims.in/jaims/article/view/3297

Manuscript Received Review Round 1 Review Round 2 Review Round 3 Accepted
2024-04-08 2024-04-18 2024-04-29 2024-05-09 2024-05-17
Conflict of Interest Funding Ethical Approval Plagiarism X-checker Note
Authors state no conflict of interest. Non Funded. The conducted research is not related to either human or animals use. 11.13 All authors have accepted responsibility for the entire content of this manuscript and approved its submission.

© 2024by Sonam Kumari Keshari, Avadhesh Kumar, Neelam Gupta, Deena Nath Singh, Jai Shankar Prasadand Published by Maharshi Charaka Ayurveda Organization. This is an Open Access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ unported [CC BY 4.0].

Introduction

Mootra-Ashmari is a state in which a structure like a stone is developed in Basti. This structure is generated by the solidification of Shukra, Vata, Pitta, and Kapha, caused by the Ushma Guna of Pitta combined with Shoshana Karma of Vayu, and is then further covered by Dosha. Ashtamahagada includes Mootra-Ashmari, indicating the seriousness of the illness. Acharya Charaka has mentioned Basti and Vankshana is the root of Mootravaha Shrotasa.

Niruktti of Ashmari[1]

पाषाण प्रस्तर ग्रावोपलास्मानः शिलादृषत् ॥..... अमरकोष

Ashmari word originates from Ashma word.
Ashma = Patthar (Stone)
Ashmari = Hard like a stone

Vyutpatti of Ashmari[2]

अश्मानं राति ददाति या: Shabdakalpadruma

Ashma = Stone
Rati = to present

The world Ashmari is derived from Ash by applying the rule Annebhyo Drishyate and then by adding a suffix Man, the suffix denotes the quality of noun by which the word is synthesized and meaning to the word a stone or stone like substance; means the formation and presentation of Ashma (stone) like substances.

Aim and Objectives

1. To study the literary review of Mootra-Ashmari according to Ayurvedic Samhitas and modern medical science.
2. To understand the Ayurvedic concepts of Nidana, Poorvaroopa, Lakshana, Upashaya, and Samprapti of Mootra-Ashmari.

Materials and Methods

All textual references of Mootra-Ashmari are collected from the Ayurvedic classics in the library of Govt. P.G. Ayurvedic College and Hospital Chaukaghat, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh.

Nidana[4,6]

includes all the etiological factors. The knowledge of Nidana is helpful for the proper diagnosis, prevention of disease and treatment also.

Sushruta has described the causative factors of Ashmari separately. The process of urinary calculi formation as described by Acharya Sushruta is as follows:

तत्रासंशोधनशीलस्यापथ्यकारिणः प्रकुपितः श्लेष्मा मूत्रसम्पृक्तोऽनुप्रविश्य बस्तिमश्मरीं जनयति|| (सुoनिo3/4)

When an individual who neglects to cleanse (Samsodhana) the internal channels of his organs or is in the habit of taking Mithyaahaar-Vihaar like Apathyakari then vitiated Shleshma mixed with Bastigatamootra entered in Basti form Mootra-Ashmari. Here, it becomes saturated with the stone forming substances and provides rise to the formation of concretion or gravels to pass through the urine. So, an abundance of vitiated Shleshma Dosha should be taken in to consideration because the underlying cause of Mootra-Ashmari.

According to Acharya Charaka[6]

व्यायामतीक्ष्णौषधरूक्षमद्यप्रसङ्गनित्यद्रुतपृष्ठयानात् |
आनूपमत्स्याध्यशनादजीर्णात् स्युर्मूत्रकृच्छ्राणि नृणामिहाष्टौ ||च.चि.26/32

Ati Vyaayaama, Teekshna Aushadha, Ruksha Madya Sevana, Drutaprishthayaana, Aanoopamaamsa Sevana, Matsya Sevana, Adhyashana, Ajeerna Bhojana.

According to Vagbhata

Snigdha Aahaara Sevana, Divaaswapna, Ajeerna Bhojana, Madhura Aahaara, Adhyashana.

Poorvaroopa[9]

According to Madhav Nidana

Bastyaadhmanam (distension of the urinary bladder), Aasandeshesu Parito Atiruja (severe pain around bladder), Mutre Bastasagandhatwam (uriniferous odour due to dribbling), Mutrakrichchhra (dysuria), Jwara (fever), Aruchi (anorexia)

As per Acharya Sushruta

Bastipeeda, Arochaka, Mutrakrichchhra, Bastishiromushkashephasa Vedana, Jwara, Bastigandhatwam.

Roopa[4]

According to Acharya Sushruta: Common symptoms of Mootra-Ashmari are Mahati Vedana in Nabhi, Basti Sevani and Mehana during urination,


Mootradharasanga, haematuria, Mootravikirana, Gomedakaprakasha like clear urine, urine mixed with gravel. Pain occurs during running, crossing, swimming, riding and walking.

According to Acharya Vagbhatta: Ruja Nabhi-Basti-Sevani-Medhra (pain in the perineum and neck of the bladder which radiates to the back down the thighs, but is especially noticed at the end of the penis immediately after micturition), Visheernadhara Mutra, Saraktata (haematuria), Mutradhara Sanga (sudden ceasing of flow of urine), Sasiktam Mutram Visrajati (passing of gravels).

Bheda[4],[5]

चतस्रोऽश्मर्यो भवन्ति; श्लेष्माधिष्ठानाः; तद्यथा- श्लेष्मणा, वातेन, पित्तेन, शुक्रेण चेति ||(सुoनिo 3/3)

1) Vataja 2) Pittaja 3) Kaphaja 4) Shukrashmari

CharactersVataja[5]Pittaja[5]Kaphaja[5]
ShapeKadamba Pushpavat Kantakachita Bhallatakasthi Pratima, Ashmatulya, SamsthanaKukkutand Prateekasha, Shweta, Snigdha
ColourShyava Varna Madhu Varna
Sarakta,Peetavbhasita,Krishna
Madhuka Pushpa Varna (Su)
Madhu Varna (A.H)
LakshanaTeevra Vedana, Patient bites his teeth, presses umbilicus, frequently rubs penis, touches anus, passes flatus, feels burning sensation while passing urine, wind, urine and feces are excreted with difficultyUshyta, Chushyata Dahyata
and Pachyata type pain in the
bladder.
Dalana, Bhedana and Todana type of pain. Bladder becomes Guru and Sheeta.
Modern correlation Calcium oxalate stonesUric acid stonePhosphate stone

Shukrashmari[5]

The stone developed in seminal vesicle due to suppression of Shukra. If Shukra Vega is suppressed it takes Vimargagamana and lodged in between Medhra and Vrishana. At this stage Vata dries up the Shukra and Shukrashmari is formed. It is compared to Spermolith.

Clinical features of Shukraja Ashmari[5]

Shukraja Ashmari exhibits symptoms such as painful urination, discomfort in the Basti and Vrishana, Swayathu in Vrishana, etc.

Clinical features of Sharkara (gravel)[10]

Gravel, sand, or ash-like substances in urine are cause of altered appearances of urinary calculi. Urinary calculi and gravel share similarities in terms of discomfort. The stone come out with urine when Vayu is favourable and calculi are tiny.

Complication of Sharkara[10]

Those (gravel) get stuck up on their passage through urethra and produce complications such as weakness, lethargy, emaciation, pain in flanks, dislike for food, pallor, Usna-Vata (cysto-urethritis), thirst, pain in pericardium and vomiting.

Samprapti[4,7]

Acharya Sushruta gave two examples of how Ashmari forms: when clear water is kept in a new pitcher, slush forms over time. Similarly, stone forms in Basti from urine after sometime, and rainwater solidifies to form hail stones by action of air and fire of electricity. Similarly, in Basti Vata Pitta mixed with urine to form Ashmari by binding Kapha.[4]

According to Acharya Charaka when Vayu covers mouth of bladder and dries up urine, then urine gets mixed with Pitta, Kapha, and Shukra giving rise to the formation of Ashmari just as Gorochana gets formed Pitta in body of Gau.[7]

Samprapti Ghataka

  • Nidana : Kapha, Vaata Prakopaka
  • Dosha : Kapha Pradhaana Tridosha
  • Dooshya : Mootra
  • Shrotasa : Mootravaha
  • Shrotodushti : Sanga
  • Agni : Jatharaagnimaandya
  • Aama : Jatharaagni
  • Dosha Maarga : Koshtha, Shaakha
  • Roga Maarga : Aabhyaantara
  • Udbhava Sthaana : Pakvaashaya
  • Adhishthaana : Basti (Mootravaha Shrotasa)

Upashaya - Anupashaya

The factors which relieve the signs and symptoms of a disease are called the Upashaya, where as the factors that provoke the disease is called Anupashaya.


Upashaya is a guideline to combat the disease. It consists not only Aushadha but also Aahaara, Vihaara and all the supportive measures that take part in the elimination of disease process.

None of the Ayurvedic classics has mentioned the Upashaya and Anupashaya in relation to Ashmari. But logically Ashmari is a Kapha dominant disease, so all the measures leading to the control of Kapha may be considered as Upashaya. Similarly, all the measures that vitiate Kapha and all the Nidanas of Ashmari may be considered as Anupashaya of Ashmari.

Pathya-Apathya[13]

PathyaApathya
AaharYava, Kulattha, Puran Shali, Madya. Andaras, Puran Kushmand and Lata, Gokhura, Varun Saag, Aadraka, Pashanbheda, Yavakshar, Renuka, Shalparni. Amla,Vistambhi Aahar, Ruksha, Guru Anna Paan, Viruddha Anna Paan Sewan
ViharBasti Karma, Vamana, Virechan, Langhan, Swedan, Avagahan, Ambu Sevan Mutra Vega Vidharan, Shukra Vega Vidharan

Modern view of Mootra-Ashmari[15]

According to modern this is known as Urolithiasis/Nephrolithiasis. Renal stone or calculus or lithiasis is one of the most common diseases of the urinary tract.

It occurs more frequently in men than in women. Urinary calculus is a stone-like body composed of urinary salts bound together by a colloid matrix of organic materials. It consists of nucleus around which concentric layers of urinary salts are deposited.

Etiology[14]

  • Dietetic- Vitamin A deficiency: It causes desquamation of epithelium which acts as a nidus for stone formation.
  • Climate: In hot climate urinary solutes will increases with decrease in colloids, which leads to chelation of solute with calcium forming a nidus for stone.
  • Citrate level in urine (300-900 mg/24 hours): maintains the calcium phosphate and carbonate in soluble state and any decrease in citrate level in urine causes stone formation.
  • Infection in kidney: Urea splitting organisms commonly cause stone formation. i.e., E.coli, Staphylococcus, Streptococcus, Proteus.
  • Prolonged immobilisation causes decalcification of bones and so hypercalciuria leading to stone formation.
  • Hyperparathyroidism causes hypercalciuria causing multiple bilateral stones or often bilateral nephrocalcinosis (5%).
  • Hyperoxaluria as a result of altered glycine metabolism.
  • Cystinuria (Autosomal recessive)
  • Stasis: due to obstruction to urine flow.
  • Medullary sponge kidney.
  • Randall’s plaque theory is erosion and deposition of urinary salts as Randall’s plaque at the apex of renal papillae.
  • Carr’s postulates states that minute concretions called as microliths normally develop in the subendothelial part of the tubule which will be carried away as particles by renal lymphatic network vessels. If these lymphatics are blocked, microliths enlarge and act as a nidus for stone formation.
  • Others: Sarcoidosis,myelomatosis,gout,idiopathic hypercalciuria,hypervitaminosis D,neoplasms on treatment, hypomagnesuria ( Mg++ in urine acts as complexing agent and prevents nucleation normally).
  • Renal tubular acidosis:

    commonly calcium phosphate stone(10%).

Types of renal calculi[15]: Two major groups-

1.Primary stones,
2.Secondary stones

1. Primary stones are those which appear in apparently healthy urinary tract without any antecedent inflammation. These stones are usually formed in acid urine. These stones usually consist of calcium oxalate, uric acid, urates, cystine, xanthine or calcium carbonate.

2. Secondary stonesare usually formed as the result of inflammation. The urine is usually alkaline. as urea splitting organisms are most often the causative organisms. Triple phosphates (mixed/struvite/staghorn), amorphous phosphates, ammonium urate, phosphates stones.


Sign and Symptoms

Renal calculi are known to cause severe pain and Symptoms of renal calculi may occur only when the stone begins to move towards the ureters.

This severe pain is termed as renal colic, seen only on one side of your abdomen and in men, pain may radiate to the groin region.

Other symptoms renal calculi include:

  • Vomiting
  • Nausea
  • Foul-smell urine
  • Fever with Chills
  • Frequent urination
  • Blood in urine sample (red, pink, or brown urine) - hematuria
  • Urinating small amounts of urine.

Investigation

  • CBC, Sr. Creatinine, Blood Urea
  • Kidney function test
  • X-ray KUB, CT Scan
  • USG Abdomen with KUB

Discussion

Acharya Sushruta considered Ashmari as a grave disease (Astamahagada).[3] In modern science, it can be correlated with renal stone. Pain is the most typical presenting sign of a stone. Similar to calcium oxalate stones, tiny, moving calculi in Vataja Ashmari induce periodic colicky discomfort, or renal pain. Pittaja Ashmari is comparable to uric acid stones and hyperconcentration of fluids associated with inflammation and haematuria. The stone's large size and dull anguish are reminiscent of Kaphaja Ashmari. It is comparable to calculi of phosphate. Among the Samanya Lakshana[5] are Mahati Vedana in Nabhi, Basti Sevani and Mehana during urination, Mootradharasanga, haematuria, Mootravikirana, Gomedakaprakasha like clear urine, urine mixed with gravel. Pain occurs during running, crossing, and swimming, riding and walking. In ancient times, Ashmari was diagnosed only on the basis of the Lakshana but in present era it's tough to make a diagnosis based just on clinical findings.

The diagnosis process in use now is limited to imaging methods, such as radiography, CT scanning, ultrasound, and so on, which have improved the disease's diagnostic potential.

Conclusion

When there is a stone or calculus in the urinary system, it is called urolithiasis. The existence of stone in the Mutravahashrotas is known as Mootra-Ashmari. Mootra-Ashmari is under the category of eight grave illnesses(Astamahagada)[3] that Acharya Sushruta brought up. There are extrinsic as well as intrinsic causes of urolithiasis. As Asamshodhanasheela, Mutravegarodha, and Shukra Vegarodha are the main causes of it, according to various Acharyas. All other Acharyas, with the exception of Charaka, spoke about Vishesha Purvarupa of Mutrashmari.

Samprapti and Rupa are described in length in the classics. Urolithiasis is classified on the basis of size, X-ray characteristics, aetiological basis, stone composition and origin. Primary stones include oxalate calculi, uric acid stones, cystine calculi, xanthine calculi, and indigo calculi. Examples of secondary stones are phosphate and mixed stones. Treatment recommendations include surgery and conservatory management.

References

1. Shabdakalpadruma

2. Sastri Hara Govinda, Amarakosha, Chaukhambha publication 2006, page no 284

3. Shastri AD, Sushruta Samhita, Vol 1, Sutra Sthana 33/4, Varanasi, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan

4. Shastri AD, Sushruta Samhita, Vol 1, Nidana Sthana 3/3,4, Varanasi, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan

5. Shastri AD, Sushruta Samhita, Vol 1, Nidana Sthana 3/7-17, Varanasi, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan

6. Charaka Samhita Chikitsa Sthana 26/32, Vd Brahmanand Tripathi, Chaukhamba prakashan

7. Charaka Samhitaa Chikitsaa Sthana 26/36, Vd Brahmanand Tripathi, Chaukhamba prakashan

8. Ashtanga Samgraha Nidana Sthana 9/9


9. Upadhyaya YN, Madhav Nidana 1, Varanasi; Chaukhambha Prakashan; 2012. p. 639

10. Upadhyaya YN, Madhav Nidana 1, Varanasi; Chaukhambha Prakashan; 2012. p. 645

11. K.R. Srikantha, Vagbhatas Astanga Hrdayam, vol 2, Nidana Stana 9/6-7, Chaukhambha Krishnadas Academy Reprinted 2014, page no 85.

12. Srikamtamurhy K.R., Vagbhata’s Ashtanga Hridaya Samhita with English translation Vol-II, Nidana Sthana 9/9-10, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi

13. Bhaisajya Ratnavali siddhiprada hindi byakhya by prof. Siddhinandan mishr,2021 edition/chaptr36/Ashmari Rogadhikar/69,70 71, page number-695

14. SRB’s manual of surgery, published by Sriram Bhat M., 5th edition, page no. 1015-1016

15. A concise textbook of surgery, Published by Dr. S Das, 5th edition, page no. 1189, 1190