E-ISSN:2456-3110

Case Report

Nasal Polyp

Journal of Ayurveda and Integrated Medical Sciences

2024 Volume 9 Number 9 SEPTEMBER
Publisherwww.maharshicharaka.in

Ayurvedic management of Nasa Arsha w.s.r. to Nasal Polyp: A Case Report

Malaviya P1*, DB Vaghela2
DOI:10.21760/jaims.9.9.42

1* Poonam Malaviya, Post Graduate Scholar, Department of Shalakya Tantra, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar, Gujarat, India.

2 DB Vaghela, HOD and Professor, Department of Shalakya Tantra, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar, Gujarat, India.

Nasa Arsha is one among the Nasagata Roga explained in Ayurvedic classics. When the Prakupit Dosha gets localised in the Ghran Pradesh, the person gets the symptoms like Pratishyaya (cold), Atim Matra Kshavathu (excessive sneezing), Kruchchhra Uchchhawas (difficulty in breathing), Putinasya (fetor nasalis), Shirah Shul (headache), Anunasik Vakya Dukha (difficulty in nasal letters). Nasal polyp is oedematous grape-like protrusions most often originating in the upper part of the nose around the osteomeatal complex on the lateral wall. The surface epithelium tends to be smooth and consists of pale translucent tissue which distinguishes them from the more vascular mucosa of the nasal cavity. Polyps can vary widely in size and should be considered a bilateral condition. Rare cases of unilateral polyps should only be diagnosed. Shikhari Taila, known for its anti-inflammatory and antihistaminic properties, this medicated oil penetrates deep into the fine channels, facilitating Sroto Shodhan (cleansing of the channels).

Keywords: Shikhari Taila, Nasa Pichu, Nasa Arsha, nasal polyp

Corresponding Author How to Cite this Article To Browse
Poonam Malaviya, Post Graduate Scholar, Department of Shalakya Tantra, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar, Gujarat, India.
Email:
Malaviya P, DB Vaghela, Ayurvedic management of Nasa Arsha w.s.r. to Nasal Polyp: A Case Report. J Ayu Int Med Sci. 2024;9(9):262-266.
Available From
https://jaims.in/jaims/article/view/3647

Manuscript Received Review Round 1 Review Round 2 Review Round 3 Accepted
2024-08-14 2024-08-24 2024-09-04 2024-09-14 2024-09-26
Conflict of Interest Funding Ethical Approval Plagiarism X-checker Note
None Nil Yes 12.66

© 2024by Malaviya P, DB Vaghelaand Published by Maharshi Charaka Ayurveda Organization. This is an Open Access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ unported [CC BY 4.0].

Introduction

According to Acharya Sushruta, when a person indulges in Nidan Sevan such as excessive exposure to Raja (dust), Dhuma (smoke), intense Abhitapa (severe heat), prolonged exposure to Pravat (headwind), and the suppression of natural urges like Mutra (urination) and Purisha (bowel movement), the Prakupit Doshas invade the Ghrana Pradesh, leading to the development of Nasarsha. These aggravated Doshas lodge in the nasal region, vitiating Twak, Mamsa, and Medo, resulting in the formation of Nasarsha. Sushruta described four types of Nasarsha: Vataja, Pittaja, Kaphaja, and Sannipataja, along with four types of treatments: Aushadhi, Kshar Karma, Agnikarma, and Shastra Karma. Nasarsha can be correlated with nasal polyps.[1] The body constantly attempts to expel unwanted substances, a process that can be correlated with the Chala quality of Vata, particularly Vyana Vayu and Prana Vayu for Urdhva Jatru. When the Nidana (causative factors) are excessive, the Samprapti (pathogenesis) of the disease becomes more complex, leading the body to intensify its efforts to expel these excessive vitiated Dosha from the body.[2] Nasal polyps, associated with conditions like rhinosinusitis, cystic fibrosis, and allergic fungal sinusitis, can be understood as hypersensitivity reactions primarily driven by Vata, aimed at eliminating excess from the body.[3] Therefore, the primary focus should be on avoiding the Nidana and implementing Shodhana (purification), Shamana (pacification), and Prakriti Sthapana (restoration of normalcy) to maintain the normal physiological structure. Special emphasis should be placed on Shodhana to remove the excessively vitiated Doshas from the Urdhva Jatru (region above the clavicle) while preserving the integrity of the nasal mucosa.

The annual incidence of CRSwNP is between 1 and 20 per 1000 population. This incidence declines after 60 years of age. In the normal population the prevalence is between 1 and 4% in adults and 0.1% in children. Nasal polyps are more common in males (2-4:1). There is no racial predilection. Certain systemic diseases carry a much higher incidence of nasal polyps.[4]

Staging of Polyps can be staged based on the size

Stage I: Limited to the extent of middle turbinate

Stage II: Extending beyond the limit of Middle Turbinate.

Stage III: Approaching inferior turbinate.

Stage IV: Going up to the floor of the nose.[5]

Common side effects of intranasal corticosteroids include local irritation and epistaxis. Potential adverse events related to the administration of intranasal corticosteroids are effects on growth, ocular effects, effects on bone and effects on the hypothalamic pituitary-adrenal axis. Cases of adrenal suppression and Cushing's syndrome from systemic absorption have been reported. acute cardiac toxicity is an increasingly recognized potential adverse effect of antimicrobial drug treatment and several agents of the macrolide class of antibiotics are known to interfere with the delayed rectifier potassium current, which results in accumulation of potassium ions in cardiac myocytes and thereby delays cardiac repolarization.[6] To avoid the adverse effects of allopathic medicines, Nasa Pichu is an excellent Chikitsa (treatment)

Acharya Charaka stated that Taila(oil) is highly effective for pacifying Vata due to its qualities such as Vyavayi, Ushna, Guru, and Sneha. When processed with Aushdha (drug) that possesses Vata-pacifying properties, its medicinal benefits are enhanced.[7]

Shikhari Taila, known for its anti-inflammatory and antihistaminic properties, contains ingredients that predominantly exhibit Katu Rasa, Laghu Guna, Ushna Virya, Katu Vipaka, and Kapha-Vata-shamaka qualities. Due to its Vyavayi and Sukhshma Guna, this medicated oil penetrates deep into the fine channels, facilitating Sroto Shodhan (cleansing of the channels).

Administering this medicated oil can help reduce post-nasal and anterior nasal drips, as well as soothe irritation by delivering targeted medicine to the mucosal lining for optimal absorption. Using Nasa Pichu increases the retention time of the oil in the nasal cavity, enhancing its bioavailability and absorption. Regular application of medicated oil in the nose prevents irritation of the mucous membrane caused by allergens such as pollen, dust, and brass particles, thereby helping to manage allergies or infections. Additionally, it aids in removing unwanted substances like allergens from the nasal cavity and supports proper drainage.


Case Study

Chief Complaints with Duration: A 50-year-old male patient has been suffering from nasal stuffiness, paroxysmal sneezing, mucoidal nasal discharge, hyposmia, foul smell from the nose, and intermittent itching in the throat, nose, eyes, and ears, along with occasional frontal headaches for the past 3 years.

History of Present Illness:

Patient was asymptomatic before 3 years and gradually developed nasal congestion, difficulty in nasal breathing, excessive sneezing associated with bilateral watery discharge along with foul smell, that patient was unable to concentrate on daily activities, the symptoms worsened and frequency also increased. So he consulted an ENT specialist on nasal examination diagnosed as polyps then he was prescribed antihistamines, nasal decongestants, topical and systemic corticosteroids.

After using medication the patient got relief for a few days but recurrence of symptoms. So, the doctor suggested undergoing surgery for nasal polyp Patient was not willing to go under surgical treatment. So, a patient came to our OPD for further treatment.

Past History: History of allergy to brass particle, dust, smoke

Personal History

1. Kshudha:Poor, Agnimandya (low digestive power), Udargaurav (heaviness in abdomen)
2. Nidra:Disturbed due to difficulty in breathing, snoring
3. Mala Pravrutti: Vibandha (constipation)
4. Mutra Pravrutti: Samyak

Nasal Examination

Inspection: DNS towards Right side, mucoidal discharge in both nostrils.

Palpation: Examination of paranasal sinuses tenderness present in maxillary, frontal sinus.

Anterior Rhinoscopy: Bilateral round, pale, glossy, polypoidal masses in the middle meatus is seen Insensitive to probing, does not bleed on touch when examined by using Jobsons probe.

Posterior Rhinoscopy: Post nasal drip

Ear Examination

External Auditory Canal: Wet
TM: Retraction (Grade - 2)

Materials and Methods

A patient presenting symptoms of Nasa Arsha or nasal polyp was selected from the Shalakya Tantra OPD of ITRA Jamnagar. Both internal as well as local treatments were given to the patient. A medicinal drug was selected based on the classical reference of Chakradatta.

Table 1: Assessment Scale of Grading

Nasavarodha (Nasal Stuffiness)Score
No Obstruction0
Partially Occasional & Unilateral1
Partially Occasional & Bilateral2
Complete, Frequently & Unilateral3
Always Complete & Bilateral4
Tanu Srava (Watery Discharge)Score
No discharge0
Negligible discharge1
Intermittent discharge2
Continuous discharge3
Profuse discharge4
Ati Kshavathu (Excessive Sneezing)Score
No0
1-5 bouts per day1
6-10 bouts per day2
11-20 bouts per day3
More than 21 bouts per day4
Shirah Shoola (Headache)Score
No0
Occasional1
Intermittent2
Continuous3
Intolerable4
Nasa, Netra, Karna Kandu (Nasal, Eye, Ear Pruritus)Score
Absent0
Occasionally Present1
Often Present2
Continuously Present3
Intolerable4
Puti Nasa (Fetor Nasalis)Score
Absence of odour0
Questionable odour1
Mild Malodour2
Moderate malodour, detectable3
Strong malodour is detected4

Therapeutic Intervention

After examining the patient, we administered Vaishwanar Churna for Deepan, Pachan, and Anuloman to address digestive symptoms such as Agnimandya and Udargaurav, as Agnimandya can lead to various disorders.

Additionally, Dashmool Kwath was prescribed for Vata shaman, Arand Taila with lukewarm water was also given at bedtime to alleviate Avarana Avastha and Vacha Churna was applied locally to the nose for Sroto Shodhan after 4 days of starting the medicine, as clearing Agnimandya is the first priority before initiating any Sthanik Chikitsa.

Pathya Apathya (dietary and lifestyle guidelines)

The patient was strictly advised to avoid cold drinks, ice cream, junk food, curd, salad, fruit, fermented food items, and spicy foods. The regular intake of Sunthi Siddha Aushadha Jala throughout the day was recommended as part of their routine.

Pravat Sevan (Head wind) Diwaswapa (daytime sleeping) should be avoided, and Goghruta or Shikhari Taila was to be regularly applied to the nasal mucosa to prevent irritation from brass particles.

Table 2: Content of Shikhari Taila (Chakradatta Nasarogaadhikara)[8]

DrugBotanical NamePart UsedProportion
GruhadhoomSootAsh18gms
PippaliPiper LongumFruit18gms
DevadaruCedrus DeodaraBark18gms
YavaksharaHordeum VulgareWhole Plant18gms
KaranjaPongamia PinnataSeed18gms
SaindhavaRock Salt-18gms
ApamargaAchyranthes AsperaSeed18gms
Tila TailaSesamum OrientaleSeed Oil500ml

Nasa Pichu Procedure

Poorva Karma:Mukha Abhyanga with Bala Taila followed by Bhashpa Sweda.

Pradhana Karma:Shikhari Taila Nasa Pichu for 15 minutes in each nostril for 7 days (3 cycles) with a three day gap.

Paschat Karma:Lukewarm water Gandush and Prayogik Dhumapan were administered to the patient.

Observation and Results

Significant reduction in the presenting symptoms of the patient was seen after 3 weeks of treatment with a 3 days interval after 1 month of follow up. The patient’s condition showed gradual improvement, assessed through both subjective symptoms and objective findings. A comprehensive evaluation was performed, after completion of therapy.

Table 3: Subjective Criteria

SNSymptomsBTAfter 1st SittingAfter 2nd SittingAfter 3 SittingFollow up After 1 month
1.Nasal Stuffiness43210
2.Nasal Discharge32110
3.Sneezing43101
4.Headache10000
5.Fetor Nasalis32210
6.Itching in nose, eyes, and ears21100

jaims_3647_01.JPG

Discussion

Shikhari Taila, known for its anti-inflammatory and antihistaminic properties, Nasa Pichu increases the retention time of the oil in the nasal cavity, enhancing its bioavailability and absorption, its helps potentially reducing oedematous mucosal swelling and aiding in the dilation of constricted nasal passages.


The local action of the Pichu is attributed to the cellular absorption of the medicine, which acts as both Snehana (oleation) and Lekhana (scraping), thereby diminishing mucosal oedema.

Conclusion

Nasal polyps can be correlated with Nasa Arsha (Nasal polyp) based on their pathogenesis and clinical features. Nasapichu yields highly effective results in the treatment of Nasa Arsha (Nasal polyp). It is an economical and efficient procedure that does not cause adverse effects, unlike modern medicine.

However, modern medicine often focuses on suppressing natural reactions. In contrast, Ayurveda supports the body in expelling the Dushit Dosha that accumulates within the body. Ayurveda emphasises cleansing the body and pacifying the Tridoshas from the root through treatment modalities such as Nidana Parivarjana and Samprapti Vighatana by employing Shodhan therapies. This is accompanied by appropriate Pathya-Apathya (dietary and lifestyle guidelines). Internal medications are used to enhance Agni and strengthen the patient’s Bala. Overall, there is significant improvement in the condition, with no recurrence of symptoms. Therefore, there is a need to implement Ayurvedic treatments on a larger scale to draw more concrete conclusions.

References

1. Acharya Sushruta. Vaidya Jadavji Trikamji Acharya, Sushruta Samhita. Varanasi; Chaukhambha Orientalia; 2019. 2:270
2. Acharya Laghu Vagbhata, Ashtanga Hridayam, Sarvanga Sundara & Ayurveda Rasayana Commentary, collated by Dr. Anna Moreshwara & Ramchandra Shastri Navre, Edited by Bhishagacharya Hari Shastri Paradakar Vaidya; Chaukhamba Surbharati Publications,2020.12:193
3. Bansal Mohan, Disease of Ear, Nose & Throat with Head & Neck Surgery. 3th ed. New Delhi;Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd.2021.42:356
4. Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery.8th ed. John C Watkinson. RaymondW Clarke;CRC Press.2018.95:1038
5. Bansal Mohan, Disease of Ear, Nose & Throat with Head & Neck Surgery. 3th ed. New Delhi; Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers(P) Ltd.2021.42:357

6. Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery.8th ed. John C Watkinson.Raymond W Clarke;CRC Press.2018.95:1043
7. Vaidya Jadavji Trikamji Acharya, Charak Samhita. New Delhi: Chaukhambha Publications;2018.28:624
8. Bhaisiyaratnawali edited by Prof. Siddhinandan mishra, Hindi Commentary; Chaukhamba Surbharti publications, 2024; 63:976